District 17, encompassing some of Dartmouth's most established and desirable neighbourhoods, recorded 256 single-family listings in the analysis period, with 217 properties successfully closing at an average sale price of $542,555. This mature market demonstrates balanced conditions with 49.8% of sales closing above asking price and a healthy median days-on-market of just 7 days.
The district exhibits significant geographic price stratification across its six sub-districts: Russell Lake (17-F) commands premium pricing at $806,330 average, while Tam O'Shanter/Westphal (17-A) offers accessible entry points at $485,868. Failed listings—comprising 10 expired and 12 cancelled properties—reveal pricing sensitivities in the upper market segments, with several properties requiring strategic repositioning and substantial price corrections before ultimately transacting.
The market activity breakdown reveals strong absorption, with over 84% of listed properties successfully closing. The 8.6% failure rate (expired and cancelled combined) indicates disciplined buyer behaviour at certain price points, particularly above the $600,000 threshold.
District 17 operates as a balanced market with nearly equal proportions selling above and below list price. Properties that sold over asking averaged a premium of $27,687, while those settling below list saw an average discount of $19,360. The overall list-to-sold ratio of 101.5% confirms competitive conditions for well-priced inventory.
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Average List-to-Sold Ratio | 101.5% |
| Original-to-Sold Ratio | 100.1% |
| Properties with Price Reductions (Sold) | 40 (18.4%) |
| Average Reduction (for reduced listings) | 8.0% |
District 17's balanced market rewards strategic pricing. Properties priced at or slightly below market value move quickly—often within a week—while overpriced inventory faces extended exposure. The 7-day median DOM for sold properties stands in stark contrast to 100+ days for many failed listings, demonstrating the binary nature of pricing decisions.
District 17 comprises six distinct sub-districts, each with unique market characteristics and price points. Understanding these micro-market dynamics is essential for accurate pricing and strategic positioning.
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Price Range | $300,000 – $640,500 |
| Average SqFt | 1,710 |
| Average $/SqFt | $299.84 |
| Sold Over/At/Under Asking | 25 / 2 / 19 |
| List-to-Sold Ratio | 101.7% |
| Active Listings | 6 |
| Expired / Cancelled | 2 / 3 |
Highest Sale: Culrain Crescent — $640,500 (3 DOM, 2,198 sqft, $291/sqft)
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Price Range | $378,000 – $840,000 |
| Average SqFt | 1,806 |
| Average $/SqFt | $300.39 |
| Sold Over/At/Under Asking | 38 / 1 / 35 |
| List-to-Sold Ratio | 101.7% |
| Active Listings | 3 |
| Expired / Cancelled | 4 / 2 |
Highest Sale: Lindenwood Terrace — $840,000 (31 DOM, 2,361 sqft, $356/sqft)
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Price Range | $350,000 – $670,000 |
| Average SqFt | 1,831 |
| Average $/SqFt | $285.07 |
| Sold Over/At/Under Asking | 20 / 3 / 16 |
| List-to-Sold Ratio | 101.6% |
| Active Listings | 1 |
| Expired / Cancelled | 1 / 3 |
Highest Sale: Nausett Crescent — $670,000 (5 DOM, 1,708 sqft, $392/sqft)
With a median DOM of just 5 days and 88.6% success rate, Wildwood Lake demonstrates the strongest absorption in District 17. Well-priced properties here attract immediate buyer interest.
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Price Range | $415,000 – $1,650,000 |
| Average SqFt | 2,287 |
| Average $/SqFt | $273.38 |
| Sold Over/At/Under Asking | 11 / 0 / 6 |
| List-to-Sold Ratio | 102.7% |
| Active Listings | 2 |
| Expired / Cancelled | 1 / 1 |
Highest Sale: Bayswater Road — $1,650,000 (125 DOM, 4,143 sqft, $398/sqft)
Nantucket's 102.7% list-to-sold ratio is the highest in District 17, with 65% of sales exceeding asking price. This waterfront community commands premiums for well-positioned inventory.
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Price Range | $445,000 – $920,000 |
| Average SqFt | 2,197 |
| Average $/SqFt | $282.79 |
| Sold Over/At/Under Asking | 13 / 1 / 17 |
| List-to-Sold Ratio | 101.1% |
| Active Listings | 1 |
| Expired / Cancelled | 2 / 2 |
Highest Sale: Portland Hills Drive — $920,000 (12 DOM, 2,955 sqft, $311/sqft)
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Price Range | $575,000 – $1,225,000 |
| Average SqFt | 2,784 |
| Average $/SqFt | $293.06 |
| Sold Over/At/Under Asking | 1 / 0 / 9 |
| List-to-Sold Ratio | 97.8% |
| Active Listings | 1 |
| Expired / Cancelled | 0 / 1 |
Highest Sale: Freshwater Trail — $1,225,000 (3 DOM, 3,745 sqft, $327/sqft)
Russell Lake's 97.8% list-to-sold ratio indicates buyer negotiating power in the premium segment. Nine of ten sales closed below asking, with longer market exposure (median 20 days) typical for properties above $750,000.
| Sub-District | Sales | Avg Price | Avg $/SqFt | Median DOM | List-to-Sold |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 17-A: Tam O'Shanter/Westphal | 46 | $485,868 | $300 | 9 | 101.7% |
| 17-B: Woodlawn/Ellenvale | 74 | $517,458 | $300 | 7 | 101.7% |
| 17-C: Wildwood Lake | 39 | $504,081 | $285 | 5 | 101.6% |
| 17-D: Nantucket | 17 | $609,652 | $273 | 4 | 102.7% |
| 17-E: Portland Estates | 31 | $613,100 | $283 | 7 | 101.1% |
| 17-F: Russell Lake | 10 | $806,330 | $293 | 20 | 97.8% |
Demand concentrates in the $400K–$600K range, which captured 71% of all closed sales. The under-$400K segment offers limited but swift-moving inventory, while properties above $750K require more precise positioning and longer sale cycles.
| Price Segment | Sales | % of Market | Avg Price | Avg DOM | Avg $/SqFt |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Under $400,000 | 11 | 5.1% | $371,881 | 13 days | $302 |
| $400,000 – $500,000 | 72 | 33.2% | $443,129 | 14 days | $307 |
| $500,000 – $600,000 | 82 | 37.8% | $547,038 | 17 days | $283 |
| $600,000 – $750,000 | 40 | 18.4% | $644,576 | 16 days | $281 |
| $750,000 – $1,000,000 | 10 | 4.6% | $822,330 | 19 days | $294 |
| $1,000,000+ | 2 | 0.9% | $1,437,500 | 64 days | $363 |
The district's highest transactions demonstrate the premium potential across different sub-districts, with waterfront and executive properties commanding significant values.
Multiple streets recorded significant transaction volumes, providing meaningful pricing benchmarks for these established corridors.
Ten properties expired without selling, collectively spending an average of 97 days on market. These listings reveal pricing thresholds buyers rejected, with properties ranging from $440K to nearly $1M. Most required price reductions before expiring—yet still failed to attract acceptable offers.
Original: $998,000 → Final: $998,000 (no reduction) | 123 DOM | 2,714 sqft
Original: $775,000 → Final: $749,900 (3.2% reduction) | 44 DOM | 2,185 sqft
Original: $699,900 → Final: $659,000 (5.8% reduction) | 112 DOM | 2,279 sqft
Original: $629,500 → Final: $599,900 (4.7% reduction) | 45 DOM | 1,486 sqft
Original: $599,900 → Final: $579,900 (3.3% reduction) | 64 DOM | 1,223 sqft
Original: $599,900 → Final: $549,000 (8.5% reduction) | 59 DOM | 1,533 sqft
Original: $569,900 → Final: $532,900 (6.5% reduction) | 185 DOM | 1,581 sqft
Original: $529,900 → Final: $519,900 (1.9% reduction) | 84 DOM | 1,963 sqft
Original: $519,900 → Final: $514,900 (1.0% reduction) | 141 DOM | 1,340 sqft
Original: $449,900 → Final: $439,900 (2.2% reduction) | 112 DOM | 1,116 sqft
Eight of ten expired properties had price reductions averaging just 4.4%—insufficient corrections given their extended market exposure. The Hilton Drive property's 185 days on market with only 6.5% reduction demonstrates that incremental price cuts rarely solve fundamental overpricing. Buyers interpreted these modest adjustments as continued seller resistance rather than genuine repositioning.
Twelve listings were cancelled by sellers, representing strategic withdrawals to reassess pricing or timing. Tracking these properties reveals whether market corrections ultimately enabled transactions.
Original: $975,000 → Final: $975,000 (no reduction) | 14 DOM | 3,721 sqft
Original: $759,900 → Final: $749,900 (1.3% reduction) | 69 DOM | 2,475 sqft
Original: $724,900 → Final: $691,310 (4.6% reduction) | 163 DOM | 2,475 sqft
Original: $660,000 → Final: $660,000 (no reduction) | 20 DOM | 2,860 sqft
Original: $645,000 → Final: $645,000 (no reduction) | 25 DOM | 2,607 sqft
Original: $449,999 → Final: $449,999 (no reduction) | 36 DOM | 2,138 sqft
Original: $400,000 → Final: $400,000 (no reduction) | 10 DOM | 868 sqft
Original: $489,900 → Final: $489,900 (no reduction) | 42 DOM | 1,659 sqft
Original: $492,900 → Final: $479,500 (2.7% reduction) | 23 DOM | 1,154 sqft
Original: $444,900 → Final: $444,900 (no reduction) | 5 DOM | 2,308 sqft
Original: $429,900 → Final: $429,900 (no reduction) | 6 DOM | 1,737 sqft
Original: $429,900 → Final: $424,900 (1.2% reduction) | 68 DOM | 1,208 sqft
Three cancelled listings ultimately transacted after strategic repositioning. The Grandview Drive success required a 10% correction from original pricing and 87 total days across listings. The Alpine Drive property at 2,475 sqft failed twice—first at $749,900 (69 DOM), then at $691,310 (163 DOM)—spending a combined 232 days on market without finding a buyer, demonstrating persistent overvaluation despite multiple attempts.
Fourteen properties remain available across the district, with ten already carrying price reductions. Extended days on market for several listings suggest additional adjustments may be required to attract buyers.
| Street (Sub-District) | Current Price | Reduction | DOM | SqFt |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lakecrest Drive (17-A) | $1,250,000 | −$250,000 (16.7%) | 103 | 1,563 |
| Freshwater Trail (17-F) | $1,175,000 | −$100,000 (7.8%) | 31 | 3,438 |
| Pebblecreek Crescent (17-A) | $879,900 | −$20,000 (2.2%) | 177 | 3,369 |
| Havenbrook Hill (17-E) | $855,000 | −$20,000 (2.3%) | 157 | 2,657 |
| Donview Drive (17-D) | $669,900 | −$30,000 (4.3%) | 81 | 1,945 |
| Pauline Crescent (17-B) | $624,900 | — | 32 | 1,633 |
| Helene Avenue (17-A) | $584,900 | — | 22 | 1,750 |
| Mount Edward Road (17-A) | $549,000 | −$10,000 (1.8%) | 78 | 1,745 |
| Tantling Crescent (17-B) | $539,000 | — | 22 | 1,680 |
| Tobermory Road (17-A) | $515,000 | — | 37 | 1,248 |
| Muriel Avenue (17-B) | $499,000 | −$16,000 (3.1%) | 120 | 1,490 |
| Regal Road (17-D) | $454,900 | — | 42 | 1,700 |
| Cranberry Crescent (17-C) | $439,900 | −$10,000 (2.2%) | 57 | 1,568 |
| Aberdeen Court (17-A) | $399,900 | — | 30 | 1,383 |
The Pebblecreek Crescent property at 177 DOM and Havenbrook Hill at 157 DOM represent the oldest active listings in the district. Both have made only modest 2% reductions, yet face the compounding challenge of stale listing perception in a market that typically moves within two weeks.
Three properties are currently pending under conditional contract:
| Street (Sub-District) | List Price | Firm Date | DOM |
|---|---|---|---|
| Raymoor Drive (17-B) | $529,900 | January 12, 2026 | 37 |
| Gourok Avenue (17-A) | $499,900 | January 9, 2026 | 123 |
| Roblea Drive (17-B) | $450,000 | January 16, 2026 | 12 |
District 17 rewards accurate pricing with swift sales—the 7-day median DOM confirms that well-positioned inventory moves quickly. Nearly half of all sellers achieved premiums averaging $27,687 above asking, demonstrating that strategic underpricing can generate competitive bidding. However, the 8.6% failure rate reveals that buyers firmly resist aspirational pricing, particularly above $600,000.
The $400K–$600K segment demonstrates the strongest absorption (71% of sales), while upper-market properties ($750K+) face extended exposure averaging 28 days versus 14 days for mid-range inventory. Properties that required relisting typically needed 10-18% corrections from original pricing to ultimately transact.
Opportunities exist across all price points, with particular leverage in the upper segments. Russell Lake's 97.8% list-to-sold ratio indicates consistent negotiating room in the luxury tier. Stale active listings—seven properties exceeding 75 DOM with minimal reductions—represent potential value for patient buyers willing to negotiate.
Mid-market buyers ($400K–$600K) will encounter competition, with half of sales in this segment exceeding asking price. Be prepared to act decisively on well-priced listings, particularly in Wildwood Lake (17-C) where median DOM is just 5 days.
District 17's mature neighbourhoods deliver strong fundamentals: 84.8% sale success rate, balanced pricing performance, and efficient 7-day median time-to-sale. Sub-district variations are pronounced—from Nantucket's 102.7% seller premiums to Russell Lake's buyer-favouring 97.8%—underscoring the importance of hyper-local market intelligence. Failed listings averaging 97 DOM stand in stark contrast to successful sales at 16 DOM, demonstrating the costly consequences of overpricing in this well-informed market.